film movie review

The Greatest Showman Review

by Ian Morton

Now that La La Land has reinvigorated the musical, it was only a matter of time before rival studios jumped on the proverbial bandwagon to take advantage of the resurrected genre. With many productions in development across all major studios, it’s 20th Century Fox out the gate first with the entertaining but largely forgettable, The Greatest Showman.

Inspired by the life and times of PT Barnum, Hugh Jackman takes on the role of ringmaster in a story exploring the famed businessman during the creation and promotion of the Barnum and Bailey Circus.

In terms of direction it’s relatively simple fayre, with little innovation in terms of visuals and general framing. Forcibly packing in much more than is needed, the film does struggle with pacing and tone but considering its overall aim isn’t necessarily to win any awards come Oscar season, these issues are hardly offensive.

As you probably expect from La La Land collaborators Benj Pasek and Justin Paul, the toe tapping songs are more than enough to keep you entertained for just shy of 2 hours. Similar to Baz Luhrmann’s, Moulin Rouge and Rob Marshall’s, Chicago, the modern take does work for the most part within the wider context of the story but occasionally feels out of place, leading to some surprisingly jarring moments.

As mentioned, the story itself is told at lightning speed, opting to ignore any real depth in order to fit in as much as they can. The same effect is felt when trying to establish the direction of its moral compass. As with most films around the holidays, there are a few morals to take home but they all seemingly get lost in the crowd when trying to work out what The Greatest Showman is really trying to say. While on the surface this may not seem like particularly bad thing, the overall product never really adds up to the sum of its parts as the final scenes just meld together without any real pay off.

Heading things up nicely is the lead performance from Hugh Jackman. Setting the scene early, Jackman shines as PT Barnum in a role that benefits from the natural charisma and likability exuding from the Aussie actor. Seeing Zac Efron jumping back into song and dance is certainly a sight for sore eyes but it’s just a shame he isn’t given more, particularly as one of the best scenes is a cheeky set piece with Him and Jackman just chewing things up!

In reality, this is a point and shoot film from a relatively inexperienced director rather than genre challenging masterpiece from one more experienced. While the songs don’t entirely work and story is slightly overstuffed, altogether it’s a relatively inoffensive way to spend a Sunday afternoon! 3 out of 5 stars.

Check out what we thought of last year with our top 10 of 2017:

Top 10 films of the year – The Big Dudes perspective!





2 comments on “The Greatest Showman Review

  1. All Things Movies - Morton

    Thanks for the comment! People are certainly loving it – the IMAX and sing-a-long versions are definitely a sign that this is something audiences want to see more of!

    I think some of the set pieces were amazing – particularly the Efron/Jackman bar scene – that was really good fun and had me tapping along for a few days after too!

    The real thing for me though was that it was more a set of music videos than a film – take away the story and you have some really impressive set pieces and some awesome songs but no more than that!

    I’m really pleased you enjoyed it though – it’s what cinema is all about!


  2. MovieGoer

    I understand from a critic’s viewpoint that you can’t rave about this film. However, as a simple movie-goer, I loved this movie. As did everyone else I know who saw it. I posted about it on Facebook and got tons of comments agreeing with me. No one had anything negative to say about this movie, in fact, most people who saw it are eager to see it again. I’m an amateur video editor, and I loved the editing of this movie – clever and seamless transitions from one scene to the next. Sure….it wasn’t a deep, complex, mind-bending movie. No. It was a feel-good, energetic, upbeat movie (like movies were once upon a time). Plus, the talent was undeniable. As far as I am concerned, this far surpassed La La Land. It’s a shame it didn’t get nominated for more, even though it will win for This Is Me. Check out the user reviews of the non-critics. It’s fairly unanimous that this movie is extremely popular and well-loved by the audience for which it was created.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: